Dessert Pies
A sweet pie for every taste bud. We bake classic cream pies year round. You can’t go wrong with any of them. I promise. All our custards and fillings are made with real ingredients, like cream, sugar and butter. No mixes, flavorings or powders. Our seasonal fruit pies are baked only when the local orchards are ripe with fruit. So you better get one while you can! And the same goes for our specialty pies, each season comes with a new variety of flavors.
-
Apple Crumble
$24.00 Order for PickupFresh sliced apples smothered in cinnamon and spices then topped with an oat streusel.
-
Apple Hand Pies
$15.00 Order for PickupFresh apples peeled and cooked in a caramel sauce and then wrapped in our flakey pie crust.
-
Berry Cream
$25.00 Order for PickupA smooth and creamy, nearly fluffy cheesecake filling topped with seasonal berries.
-
Cookie Butter Banana
$22.00 Order for PickupOur traditional banana cream pie with a layer of Biscoff cookie spread covering the bananas. A terrific treat.
-
Peach Cream
$25.00 Order for PickupA whipped cheesecake filling topped with fresh glazed peaches.
-
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream
$22.00 Order for PickupA thin layer of peanut butter with chocolate custard and fresh whipped cream. The perfect balance
-
Pear Chai
$24.00 Order for PickupSoft pears baked with chai spices, and covered in a full pie crust.
-
Pumpkin
$22.00 Order for PickupA classic that is as smooth as it is beautiful.
-
Sour Cream Lemon
$22.00 Order for PickupEveryone’s favorite pie. Not quite custard and not quitea lemon curd it’s the perfect tang and texture to compliment a sour cream and cream cheese topping.
-
Sugar Cream
$22.00 Order for PickupThink creme brulee baked into a pie. Serve chilled or even frozen! My personal favorite
-
Banana Cream
$22.00 Order for PickupFresh bananas sliced and then smothered with a ultra creamy vanilla custard. Chilled and topped with whipped cream and dried bananas
-
Berry Crumble
$24.00 Order for PickupFresh Strawberries, Blueberries, Raspberries and Blackberries topped with a oat crumble.
-
Strawberry Cream
$25.00 Order for PickupA cream filling that is light and decadent at the same time topped with sliced strawberries and a guava glaze.
-
Black Bottom Oatmeal
$22.00 Order for PickupAn ode to the oatmeal chocolate chip cookie, but better. We bake it into our flakey pie crust.
-
Blueberry
$24.00 Order for PickupFresh blueberries sweetened with sugar and fresh lemon zest baked into a perfect lattice crust.
-
Buttermilk Custard
$22.00 Order for PickupOld-Fashioned pie has a super smooth, custard-like filling that is really sweet.
-
Butterscotch Custard
$22.00 Order for PickupThis pie is reminiscent of an old-fashioned ice-cream sundae. Bursting with brown sugar and butter flavors in a ultra smooth and creamy custard.
-
Cherry
$25.00 Order for PickupA summer time classic. Fresh cherries baked under a braided golden lattice.
-
Chocolate Chess
$22.00 Order for PickupThink a gooey brownie baked into a pie.
-
Chocolate Cream
$22.00 Order for PickupA creamy chocolate custard topped with whipped cream and drizzled with chocolate.
-
Chocolate Peppermint
$22.00 Order for PickupOur original Chocolate Cream pie with a peppermint whipped cream is the perfect holiday treat.
-
Coconut
$22.00 Order for PickupA classic coconut custard made with shredded coconut and coconut milk topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut.
-
Cookie Pie
$22.00 Order for PickupOur favorite chocolate chip cookie baked into a pie! Eat warm with ice cream and its heavenly
-
Cranberry Key Lime
$24.00 Order for PickupA festive holiday pie, this tart key lime makes for a fresh pie in the heavy holiday seasons.
-
Custard Pie
$22.00 Order for PickupAn old fashioned custard pie. Very southern and very simple.
-
Dutch Peach
$25.00 Order for PickupFresh peaches baked to gooey perfection underneath a golden crumble.
-
Eggnog
$20.00 Order for PickupA ginger snap crust filled with eggnog custard. Topped with whipped cream and fresh nutmeg.
-
Fresh Peach
$26.00 Order for PickupFresh peaches from local orchards drizzled with homemade glaze
-
German Chocolate
$25.00 Order for PickupA baked chocolate custard topped with homemade coconut and pecan frosting.
-
Grapefruit Custard
$22.00 Order for PickupThe filling blends honey, sugar, and plenty of fresh grapefruit juice making this an unexpected delight.
-
Key Lime Pie
$23.00 Order for PickupA housemade graham cracker and gingersnap crust with a delicate and tart key lime custard, topped with whipped cream.
-
Mint Chocolate
$22.00 Order for PickupA mint chocolate brownie baked into a pie. What could be better? Nothing.
-
Orange Dreamsicle
$22.00 Order for PickupA wafer cookie crust with a dreamy orange filling topped with an orange whipped cream. It’s fresh and perfectly sweet.
-
Pecan
$25.00 Order for PickupA fall classic. Toasted pecans add the best crunch to this sweet pie.
-
Ruby Red
$25.00 Order for Pickup(Fresh Strawberry)–A sweetened cream cheese holds a heaping pile of fresh strawberries and homemade glaze.
-
S’more Pie
$22.00 Order for PickupThe ultimate summer time treat baked into a pie! A homemade graham cracker crust, with a baked milk chocolate ganache then topped with homemade marshmallow fluff and toasted to perfection
-
Salted Caramel Apple
$25.00 Order for PickupA salted caramel sauce layered between fresh cut apples and covered with a lattice.
-
Snack Crack Pie
$26.00 Order for PickupOur gluten free pie. A gooey rice chex with pretzels, coconut, and almonds make our crust. We fill it with a vanilla bean custard and topped with whipped cream.
-
Strawberry Rhubarb
$22.00 Order for PickupThe ultimate classic- Strawberry Rhubarb. Made with fresh Strawberries and locally harvested Rhubarb.